Laravel cannot echo softdeletes field error Carbon Data Missing

I wanna check if the data has been deletes. So i use eloquent like:

$check = ModelName::withTrashed()->where("id","=",$id)
->select("id","deleted_at","other_field")
->get();

foreach ($check as $rw) {
echo $rw->id; // it print the id
echo $rw->other_field; //also print the field value
echo $rw->deleted_at; // Error:

//InvalidArgumentException in Carbon.php line 425:
//Data missing
//at Carbon::createFromFormat('Y-m-d H:i:s.000', '2016-09-19 07:06:56') in Model.php line 2955
}

Then i try to dump to see the value:

dd($check);

The result of deleted_at echo it value like:

  #attributes: array:3 [▼
    "id" => 1
    "deleted_at" => "2016-09-19 07:06:56"

via Chebli Mohamed